The injury list for the Montreal Canadiens keeps growing, and now Kaiden Guhle is the newest player added to it.
Karine Hains from The Hockey News shared that the young defenseman was clearly struggling with a serious problem starting from Game 4 of the Eastern Conference Final.
His actions during the important Game 5 showed things weren’t right. The expression on his face. The way he moved. The way he seemed unsure during easy plays. Even though no one from the team confirmed it until now, it was clear to anyone watching that something was off.
Guhle is now the fifth main player for the Canadiens linked to serious injuries this week. The list already had captain Nick Suzuki, Juraj Slafkovsky, Noah Dobson, and Lane Hutson, as mentioned in earlier reports.
The 24-year-old defenseman ended the regular season having played only 39 games while costing the team $5.55 million against the salary cap. Injuries have been a problem for him since he started playing professionally.
Despite this, he played in all 16 of Montreal’s playoff games, contributing 8 assists and holding a plus-4 rating. His performance stayed strong, although it slipped a bit towards the end.
Why everyone is focusing on Martin St-Louis’s choice
Many analysts are wondering the same thing. Should Martin St-Louis have taken Guhle out of the game once it was obvious he wasn’t able to play up to his usual standards?
Knee injuries can get worse quickly. One wrong move in a playoff game can mean months of recovery afterward. The risk can become serious when the pressure of winning is higher than keeping players healthy.
Arber Xhekaj missed three playoff games during that same series. The 25-year-old has been a solid physical player with 13 playoff games under his belt, including one goal and a plus-5 rating, even with limited playtime.
Some fans think Xhekaj could have made a bigger impact in Game 5 when being tough was important. But others argue that taking a top defender out right before getting knocked out of the playoffs would have been an even bolder choice.
Honestly, most NHL coaches in St-Louis’ situation would have done the same thing. Experienced players want to be on the ice. Younger players want more chances to play. Saying no during a game where losing means going home is one of the toughest parts of being a head coach.
The bigger problem is the trend. Five key players are said to have serious injuries while trying to go far in the playoffs. This is not just bad luck. It’s the type of situation that coaching teams need to think about earlier in the season.
General Manager Kent Hughes will provide a complete health update in the coming days. The team usually waits for the off-season cleanout to give specific details. Everyone is preparing for what the update will reveal.
Now, conversations for the off-season are going to focus on decisions about surgery, recovery times, getting ready for training camp, and how to plan the team around several players healing at the same time.
Guhle has dealt with pain throughout his entire NHL career. His bravery is not in doubt. The real question is if that bravery should have limits during a certain series of games that were always going to be a challenge.
Martin St-Louis has a few weeks to think about his choice. The organization has several years to deal with what happens next for Guhle’s health.
The Habs’ spring ended in Carolina. The total cost of medical care is still being calculated in Montreal.
Leave a Reply