According to a popular view, American performers will not perform in Canada. Brady Tkachuk is no longer a Senator, and Quinn Hughes is no longer a Canuck, to name a few.
Drew Livingstone was the source of the take. He “on the way out” of Winnipeg lined up Quinn Hughes, Tkachuk, and Connor Hellebuyck, and then wondered if Auston Matthews was next.
Therefore, let’s look at the list. This is a commentary account, not a report, and the names vary from confirmed to mere conjecture.
Begin with what is true. Tkachuk was officially traded from Ottawa to Florida in exchange for three first-round selections and one second-round selection. Fresh from collecting 76 points, Quinn Hughes, 26, is now a Minnesota defense player.
There are two American players that departed Canadian clubs. The take has a real grain in that portion.
The first two names remain valid. After that, the issue begins.
The point at which the trend shifts from being a pattern to being pure speculation
The third name should be examined. Hellebuyck remains a Jet on an $8.5 million contract. While “on the way out” transforms a rumor into a fact it hasn’t deserved, he’s appeared on the wish-list of cap-strapped rivals.
That’s a huge leap. A genuine departure from a player and a fantasy trading target are two different things.
Then there’s Matthews. The “next?” is a guess, and a few days ago, a different account said the reverse. Nothing is verified, and he is still a Leaf coming off 53 points.
This is where the thesis truly fails. Two moves with their own backstories don’t indicate a tendency related to nationality, and “American Olympians don’t want to play in Canada” is a sweeping generalization.
Think about the circumstances. Bruce Garrioch reports that Tkachuk left because of a scenario that Ottawa wanted to see end. Quinn Hughes’s move was motivated by a variety of factors. Rather than a blanket refusal to go north, players depart for fit, term, and team orientation.
Two celebrities did go, and it is something to pay attention to. It’s up to you to decide whether it’s a trend or a coincidence if names like Matthews and Hellebuyck really shift.
Leave a Reply